Choosing the right 1911 pistol often comes down to the details, and one crucial aspect is the grip safety. The debate between a beavertail grip safety and the standard model is a common one among 1911 enthusiasts. This in-depth comparison will explore the key differences, advantages, and disadvantages of each, helping you make an informed decision for your next purchase or modification.
Understanding the Grip Safety's Role
Before diving into the specifics, let's establish the grip safety's fundamental function. Located at the rear of the grip, it's a passive safety mechanism. When you grip the pistol correctly, your thumb or the heel of your hand presses the grip safety down, disengaging it and allowing the pistol to fire. This prevents accidental discharge when the pistol is not being held properly.
1911 Beavertail Grip Safety: Enhanced Features and Benefits
The beavertail grip safety is an extended version of the standard grip safety. Its defining characteristic is its elongated shape, which extends further back and upward, covering a significantly larger portion of the backstrap. This seemingly small design alteration offers several advantages:
Higher Comfort and Reduced Hand Pain
The extended design of the beavertail reduces the chances of the grip safety digging into the web of your hand, a common complaint with standard grip safeties. This enhanced ergonomics lead to increased comfort, particularly during extended shooting sessions. This comfort translates to improved accuracy and control.
Improved Reliability and Function
The beavertail grip safety often features a more substantial and robust design. This enhanced build often equates to more reliable function under duress, providing a more consistent and dependable safety mechanism.
Enhanced Trigger Reach
The higher placement of the beavertail often improves the relationship between the trigger and the web of the hand. This can result in a smoother, more natural trigger pull, enhancing both comfort and accuracy.
More Complete Coverage of the Frame
The expanded coverage of the beavertail provides a more complete barrier between the hammer and the web of the hand, significantly decreasing the chance of hammer bite—a painful and potentially dangerous issue with standard grip safeties.
Standard 1911 Grip Safety: Simplicity and Traditional Design
The standard 1911 grip safety is the original design, characterized by its shorter length and more compact profile. While it may not offer the same level of comfort and hand protection as its beavertail counterpart, it possesses certain advantages:
Simpler and More Affordable
Standard grip safeties are generally less expensive to manufacture and purchase. This makes them a popular choice for budget-conscious shooters.
Familiar and Traditional
Many shooters appreciate the simplicity and traditional feel of the standard grip safety. Its familiar design and feel can contribute to a sense of comfort and confidence for those accustomed to classic 1911 designs.
Less Bulk
Its smaller profile reduces the overall bulk of the handgun, which can be appreciated by those who prioritize concealability and a slimmer grip profile.
Making the Right Choice: Beavertail or Standard?
The decision between a beavertail and a standard grip safety depends heavily on individual preferences and priorities. Consider the following:
- Hand Size and Grip: Shooters with larger hands may find the beavertail's extended coverage more comfortable, preventing hand pain and hammer bite. Those with smaller hands might find the standard grip safety sufficient.
- Shooting Style and Frequency: If you intend to shoot frequently or for extended periods, the added comfort of a beavertail grip safety will be significantly beneficial.
- Budget: Standard grip safeties present a more economical option.
- Concealability: For concealed carry, the slimmer profile of a standard grip safety might be preferable.
Ultimately, the best way to decide is to handle both types of grip safeties and determine which feels most comfortable and natural in your hand. If possible, rent or borrow pistols with both types of grip safeties to test their suitability before making a purchase. This hands-on approach will greatly enhance your ability to make the choice that best suits your needs.
